1. I haven't seen any Enterprise, so, yeah, I'm taking TOS and TNG as my canon. (And then sometimes throwing in stuff from elsewhere.)
2. Hmm, I might be able to work with that. I'm tempted to go with "Aggie," because it amuses me.
Mori's Minions
Re: Mori's Minions
Another setting! This one is original and the writing is extremely stream-of-consciousness, but I think it's a fun setting.
Tarotverse
(Nothing makes me happier than random questions about my settings, and also I am Perpetually Eager to glowfic in them, let me know!)- anthusiasm
- Posts: 484
- Joined: Fri Jun 13, 2014 7:20 pm
- Pronouns: She/her/hers
- Location: http://inquisitivefeminist.tumblr.com
Re: Mori's Minions
Do you mind giving more examples about what kinds of things writing and casting do/how the two are significantly different from each other? Can you use writing to Change The Future? Also the army thing implies that different styles of decks of cards cause changes in the spells cast that make coordinating difficult, how overt are these changes? Just aesthetic things or are the effects significantly different? Are there any kinds of theme decks that are accepted in academia (like cards that are based on Greek mythology or the works of Van Gogh or something pretentious like that)? How does tarot usage interact with religion?
Also evil tarot users are literally Kylo Ren oh my god
Also evil tarot users are literally Kylo Ren oh my god
Re: Mori's Minions
Absolutely! So the distinction is that reading just gives you information about the world and writing actually changes it.
One typical reading is a simple three-card reading (I'm drawing this directly from actual tarot stuff) where the three cards represent the past, present, and future of something (person, situation...) (Lots of websites will do this for you. Magic not included.) So the magician (...I really need a term for these. Oracle, maybe?) shuffles the cards, focuses on (say) the person they're doing a reading for, and deals out a past, present, and future. And then they can try to interpret the symbolism to figure out what that's actually telling them -- if your future is the Emperor in the standard Rider-Waite deck, that means something about authority, logic, practicality. The magician gets a little magical help with their intuition for interpreting this, but mostly it's just practical skill, you could theoretically learn it without doing any magic at all.
If the magician is doing a writing, on the other hand, they'll draw the Emperor and go "hmm, okay, normally I would think this means they're going to take a practical approach to this big upcoming thing, but I'm trying to help them out so I'm going to interpret it as meaning they're going to achieve a position of authority in the near future." And they expend some magical energy and something fitting that interpretation will happen. The more unlikely and specific and implausible the interpretation, the more energy it takes. You can definitely use writing to change the future.
On the army thing: so, for example, here are two different images of the Lovers. In the second one, the man is holding onto the woman's wrist like he's restraining her, so you could use that as a theme for a casting, maybe go for an Apollo and Daphne theme, she's trying to escape and he's trying to catch her, use it to give someone a speed boost to pursue someone else. You couldn't do that with the first image, but you could maybe do something riffing on the fact that they're both wearing crowns. By standardizing the deck, the army can say "okay, here's a dozen different castings that can correspond to this card image, practice them until you can do them in sync with everyone else in your unit."
Academia would probably be cool with a deck based on Greek mythology, just like you could write a Serious Literary Book set in Greek Mythology, but couldn't write LotR fanfiction and expect it to be treated as a Serious Literary Work. A van Gogh deck would probably be considered a bit derivative and you should be doing your own art inspired by the post-Impressionist style instead.
The religion question is one I've been poking at! There's definitely some religions that are all "this is an Abomination against the Laws of God" and maybe one or two that actually incorporate tarot stuff but I think by and large it's just treated as a separate thing from religion altogether.
One typical reading is a simple three-card reading (I'm drawing this directly from actual tarot stuff) where the three cards represent the past, present, and future of something (person, situation...) (Lots of websites will do this for you. Magic not included.) So the magician (...I really need a term for these. Oracle, maybe?) shuffles the cards, focuses on (say) the person they're doing a reading for, and deals out a past, present, and future. And then they can try to interpret the symbolism to figure out what that's actually telling them -- if your future is the Emperor in the standard Rider-Waite deck, that means something about authority, logic, practicality. The magician gets a little magical help with their intuition for interpreting this, but mostly it's just practical skill, you could theoretically learn it without doing any magic at all.
If the magician is doing a writing, on the other hand, they'll draw the Emperor and go "hmm, okay, normally I would think this means they're going to take a practical approach to this big upcoming thing, but I'm trying to help them out so I'm going to interpret it as meaning they're going to achieve a position of authority in the near future." And they expend some magical energy and something fitting that interpretation will happen. The more unlikely and specific and implausible the interpretation, the more energy it takes. You can definitely use writing to change the future.
On the army thing: so, for example, here are two different images of the Lovers. In the second one, the man is holding onto the woman's wrist like he's restraining her, so you could use that as a theme for a casting, maybe go for an Apollo and Daphne theme, she's trying to escape and he's trying to catch her, use it to give someone a speed boost to pursue someone else. You couldn't do that with the first image, but you could maybe do something riffing on the fact that they're both wearing crowns. By standardizing the deck, the army can say "okay, here's a dozen different castings that can correspond to this card image, practice them until you can do them in sync with everyone else in your unit."
Academia would probably be cool with a deck based on Greek mythology, just like you could write a Serious Literary Book set in Greek Mythology, but couldn't write LotR fanfiction and expect it to be treated as a Serious Literary Work. A van Gogh deck would probably be considered a bit derivative and you should be doing your own art inspired by the post-Impressionist style instead.
The religion question is one I've been poking at! There's definitely some religions that are all "this is an Abomination against the Laws of God" and maybe one or two that actually incorporate tarot stuff but I think by and large it's just treated as a separate thing from religion altogether.
Re: Mori's Minions
If you were doing a writing for a Bell and drew the Emperor for the future, and tried to force a position-of-authority interpretation, would this take a lot of power because they get a position with a lot of authority, or very little power because they would have gotten such a position anyway, or what?
Re: Mori's Minions
Bonus to efficiency because it's a very natural meaning to that card; bonus because you're willing to be vague about the nature of the authority (not specifically "next president of the US"); penalty because it's a lot of authority; bonus because authority is Aesthetically Correct for Bells. So it would still probably stack up to being hard (otherwise you'd have people making other people super-powerful all the time), but more doable than it would be for a random person.
ETA: That is to say, it would be easier to write a Bell as "in the future, acquires power on the 'queen of the world' scale" than it would be to write the same thing for another person. It would still probably be harder to write that for a Bell than to write "in the future, acquires power on the 'head of their neighborhood watch' scale" for some other person.
ETA: That is to say, it would be easier to write a Bell as "in the future, acquires power on the 'queen of the world' scale" than it would be to write the same thing for another person. It would still probably be harder to write that for a Bell than to write "in the future, acquires power on the 'head of their neighborhood watch' scale" for some other person.
Re: Mori's Minions
I would be willing to rule that one of the Weird Medieval Variations!
-
- Posts: 204
- Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2014 2:58 pm
- Pronouns: she/her/hers
- Contact:
Re: Mori's Minions
A time loop could be really interesting.
I don't have any specific ideas for that setting, but those kind of stories have always been really interesting.
You're elements universe seems interesting in general, so maybe I could just throw someone in.
Magic tree house could be fun too, but I don't know how historically accurate I could be. It might be more interesting if the characters had their own magic.
Hmm...
I don't know if any of my characters could particularly help Jean.
I don't have any specific ideas for that setting, but those kind of stories have always been really interesting.
You're elements universe seems interesting in general, so maybe I could just throw someone in.
Magic tree house could be fun too, but I don't know how historically accurate I could be. It might be more interesting if the characters had their own magic.
Hmm...
I don't know if any of my characters could particularly help Jean.
- anthusiasm
- Posts: 484
- Joined: Fri Jun 13, 2014 7:20 pm
- Pronouns: She/her/hers
- Location: http://inquisitivefeminist.tumblr.com
Re: Mori's Minions
I was actually asking about the difference between writing and casting, since it seems like there's a lot of potential for overlap there.