Short Stories Mafia Game Thread

[Yadal]

Crap. Maybe I misread the description or something.

I give up. I've probably lost this anyway. I'm "innocent" insofar as my roleclaim was 100% accurate, but that's hardly going to help me now.

[BlueSkySprite]

=(
Sorry, I think you maybe missed the part where the Immortal is in fact evil.

I think it's probably right to kill you for winconditions even though it is not as much fun for fun gameplay to kill people for mistakenly revealing their roles than for figuring it out from in-game things.

vote to kill Yadal

[Eva]

Given Yadal's obvious scumslip, today's lynch is pretty much decided.

Sorry, Yadal. It sucks to mess up. But for the safety of the town, you've got to die.

Lynch:Yadal

[Eva]

Also, I know this is irrelevant, but I have to ask: Is "Klaon" pronounced like "Clown"?

[pistachi0n]

vote Yadal

My voting thing counts the vote for whoever has a win condition least compatible with town. I think mafia is still less compatible than whatever Yadal has, so if my vote counts for PDV and you trust me, you should lynch him tomorrow.

[pistachi0n]

Also, I know this is irrelevant, but I have to ask: Is "Klaon" pronounced like "Clown"?

I was saying "clay-on" but I'm wondering that too.

[MTC]

Also, I know this is irrelevant, but I have to ask: Is "Klaon" pronounced like "Clown"?

I remember the sandbox with Holly/Crystal and Max suggesting that it is. Specifically, here.

[Shoal]

Preview Edit: Or he could have been killed by someone else's power, like last-game Tamien's. I wouldn't expect Sharpe to be able to, unless klaon regularly use the consensus app though?

I think you meant Tulip? Tamien was flavourcop, Tulip was paranoid gun owner. Kappa’s role from last time, town vigilante, would have worked too. So, agree with your main point: it doesn’t have to be another “mafia”, it could be another 3rd party or it could be a townie with a nightkill.

@Pistachi0n, I don’t suppose the mods will clarify for you in private whether this jumper thing is worse than mafia or better? (My expectation is that they’ll be cagey with you, but it never hurts to ask). Because last game if the jumper had jumped into the mafia early on they could have had everyone’s names and gone on to lynch them (espcially if he jumped into tamien and lynched jalapeno first, then had the nightkill that night and then future demons would have had the rest of our names. it was beyond broken that mafia could even be targetted by that.), and the jumper was harder to catch because they kept jumping all over the place and it was hard to pick the changes in behaviour. With mafia there are all kinds of associative tells between them that make them easier to catch because the mafia in general don’t want to lynch each other, though they will if they have to, they’ll usually be a bit reluctant about it.

This has been a lot of words to say that if I were a mod I have no idea which wincon I would classify as “worse”. but agree that if your ability picks pdv instead of yadal then yadal still needs to be lynched toMorrow.

[pistachi0n]

No, I'm still thinking we should lynch Yadal today because they have confirmed themselves as not town. The majority of votes are going to Yadal, I don't want a tie. What I'm saying is that since my vote right before Yadal is PDV, I'm going to use it for information. I'm pointing it out now in case I die tonight.

[Shoal]

oh! I misunderstood how your ability worked. I agree 100% that we shouldn’t force a tie.