Elcenia Mafia Game Thread

[modrony]

@Paradox
Not replying was the reply I was hoping for. It kind of freaked me when Tamien did.
What I was asking was if you tried to read BSS listpost in reaction to it.

I did think that "AB is Keo" was at least something you could have arrived at if you did.

[Shoal]

Unofficial vote count:
not voting: 1 (michaelblume)
Shoal: 1 (tamien)
Paradox: 1 (jalapeno_dude,)
Tamien: 4 paradox, modrony, anthusiasm, shoal

Navigation:
Morning 1
Evening 1/Morning 2
Evening 2/Morning 3
Evening 3/Morning 4
Evening 4/Morning 5
Evening 5/Morning 6

[Paradox]

I can understand that people think I would have been more credible if I posted earlier, I was just really busy with essays/exams and haven't had the time to do other stuff.

I think the Kappa-target makes Paradox more believable. If he was lying he didn't need to choose him as that entry. I am kind of confused why he chose to protect him actually.

Everyone had pretty much accepted that alpha had confirmed you and kappa as town so I assumed the mafia would go after one of you.

[Paradox]

@Paradox
Not replying was the reply I was hoping for. It kind of freaked me when Tamien did.
What I was asking was if you tried to read BSS listpost in reaction to it.

I did think that "AB is Keo" was at least something you could have arrived at if you did.

Oh I meant your post the other day where you listed all the people you tracked but I looked through your post history and I think you were referring to this one:

As I intensely dislike last minute drama I will post this now.
I do hope we can avoid discussing it. I certainly won't.

message

---

@Light: I may well be wrong about who you are or about any of this.
Just in case I happen to be right it might be worthwhile to look at the list of the relevant person and figure out why I said this.
Very sorry I can't be more clear. I don't want to give anything away.
If I am wrong about your identity this probably means nothing so take it with a huge grain of salt.
Do feel free to ignore if you aren't up to this.

Honestly at the time I was suspicious of you and assumed it was the beginning of some plot to try and get a doctor (if they existed) to publicly reveal themselves so I ignored it.

[jalapeno_dude]

Okay, going back and re-reading carefully.

I'm really not sure whether to believe Tamien or Paradox here. Am leaning towards Paradox because they provided a list of night actions (I don't know if Tamien did because I couldn't find Tamien's roleclaim post), and I've been null-reading Tamien.

This may have been answered downthread of where I'm at, but the roleclaim post is here. The list of night actions is:

night 1 i protected kappa, night 2 bss, and i've been protecting modrony since they roleclaimed leekath.

Shoal I'm now reading your analysis of my post. This:

Explained when prom was.

is clearly the most important part. :p

[modrony]

Prom is kind of really important :P

[modrony]

Honestly at the time I was suspicious of you and assumed it was the beginning of some plot to try and get a doctor (if they existed) to publicly reveal themselves so I ignored it.

That is kind of disappointing, but understandable.

[Tamien]

Augh what a time for my internet to have been flaking out all morning. I don't have time to read most of what's been going on and I can only get access to the forum on my phone and I don't even know if my post will go through in time, but I'm going to
vote paradox
Because apparently they are counter claiming me on Ahin?? Which uh. I was already kindof suspicious of them from previous days, but this takes the cake

[Shoal]

I wish you’d gotten here in time to defend yourself more vigorously, but i’m glad you made it in time.

I’m going to join you, because I’ve been townreading you before this and i’m still suspicious of paradox.

Vote: paradox

[jalapeno_dude]

my theory about the demon is that they need to survive to the end. every other night they jump to a new target. if they’re lynched either day or if they’re nightkilled on the first night they’re in a body then the demon loses. if they survive until the end then everyone who was demonned wins. i dont know if i’m right. that’s just my guess. i think it’s either paradox or michael for the demon but the mafia is the bigger threat, unless we can kill two birds with one stone.

(The last 10 minutes seem like a good time to talk about demons in case I die tonight)

These are roughly my speculations too. But I think there's something you (and everyone else as far as I know) is missing. Go back and look at Nights 2 and 4. There are too many deaths.

Night 2: PDV (demon), wolffreak, tau
Night 4: Alphabeta+BSS, MTC (demon), pistachi0n

If the mafia only get one kill a night they can't have killed both wolffreak and tau. It seems likelier that they killed tau as a target of opportunity after he lost a form. I don't believe that Kappa would have killed either of them.

For Night 4 people have been assuming that Kappa killed pistachi0n but I don't remember him being suspicious of them (if someone can find a post where they are please show it to me).

So, I think it's likely that each time the demon switches bodies it kills an additional person in the process. Not sure if it's random or the former host gets to direct it. If I'm right there'll be 3 deaths tonight, unless the mafia kill coincides with one of them.