Six-Day-Old Spam

[Shoal]

maybe ask modrony's advice? "do you think it's a good time for the doctor to claim, or should they hold back?" If modrony thinks you're the doctor then she's townreading you.

I'm in the middle of "summarising" my play during the game and describing how towny it is like modrony asked me to. Scare quotes because I think my summary is longer than the word count of my posts this game and i'm only on day 2. :P

@future modrony: do the work yourself next time. I can put a positive spin on my own behaviour. I have, in fact, been planning for it all game.

[Tamien]

how about:

If people have actual evidence of town alignment now really isn't the time to hold it back.

does this apply to the person who targeted BSS on night 2? i notice you don't have them on your townread list, but maybe you're trying to avoid identifying them?

[jalapeno_dude]

Tamien, I think this is a good idea. You might also consider just roleclaiming. Paradox is not on modrony's innocence list, and will presumably roleclaim if they feel threatened. I think there's a significant first mover advantage here-the first person to roleclaim will be more credible, so we'd prefer it to be you rather than Paradox. And if you roleclaim you should explicitly roleclaim as Ahin-it's the only plausible name on your rolepost, I think, and, more importantly, that's what a townie with nothing to hide would do, and just saying you're a light doesn't undercut Paradox as much.

[Tamien]

okay. i'll post this, and then wait a little bit to see if there's a response, and then claim ahin

[Tamien]

should i lie about who i've targeted on the other nights? i feel good about "protecting" kappa night 1, BSS night 2, and modrony night 5, but anthusiasm on night 3 and paradox on night 4 might look sketchy? of course, if modrony is lying about only having tracked me once, then me lying about my target would be a huge tip-off

[Shoal]

finished posting my giant thing. tl;dr: I am townier than people who are actually town! :P

but no seriously. i could write just as big a wall about how i've been obviously scum this game: coasting, copying other people's reads, being wishywashy, not doing my own homework very often, wasting time talking about theory and setupspec instead of scumhunting. Publically loosing sight of the mafia to focus on the real threat to my faction: the demon. etc etc etc.

Dear future players: do your own homework seriously.


Agree about first mover advantage.

preview-edit: you should say that you have been targetting modrony since modrony roleclaimed.

[Shoal]

so we should look up when the roleclaim was exactly. i think it was day 3 though.

[Shoal]

like there's a chance that modrony was bluffing but I think it's a bigger chance that modrony thinks modrony is alive due to light protection

[Tamien]

alright, i'll look up when the roleclaim was

[Tamien]

it's here, which is the day after tau, wolffreak, and pdv died, which, yeah seems to have been day 3