Alicornutopia

@Tamien
I'll confess I was kinda using you as a scum detector.
You were suspicious enough that when Shoal and jalapeno didn't attack you even to defend themselves, even after I posted the links to the evidence, I counted it as evidence of their guilt.

okay, done everything except bathed which can happen later at night and spent time with the cats which maybe i can multitask on. i’ve got one on my lap at the moment.

I thought kappa was the one who started the list posts?

I think this is a whether or not clause: if I’d gone after tamien after you two both seemed to confirm each other as town then that would have made me look guilty, no? it seemed like you and tamien were town so i looked elsewhere. now i think that one of paradox, tamien is guilty and it looks like i’ve prioritised the day incorrectly because i did look through paradox’s posts but i haven’t had a chance to look through tamien’s again yet. I don’t know which of them is more likely to be town or not. I don’t know why people are sheeping me about paradox.

anyway, by your logic, i dont think wecan all be scum together because they certainly didn’t mind attacking me earlier.

Shoal wrote:

votecount wrote:

Unofficial vote count:
not voting: 1 (michaelblume)
Shoal: 1 (tamien)
Paradox: 2 (shoal, jalapeno_dude,)
Tamien: 3 paradox, modrony, anthusiasm

Navigation:
Morning 1
Evening 1/Morning 2
Evening 2/Morning 3
Evening 3/Morning 4
Evening 4/Morning 5
Evening 5/Morning 6

I dont really remember you posting evidence against tamien before but there’s been so much going on today i could have missed it. i’ll go back and read through your posts now.

I meant the lists with the beginnings and the ends. The sherlock.. and that was Aestrix wasn't it? Argh need reread.
I do think Tamien kept up the practice here thou. A smart thing to do. Even if I now think it was camouflage.

I did tell you guys my reasons to think she was a light. It was not ironclad.
I posted links to them for you guys to look at.
So when you jumped to 99% on that I found it weird.

If you had gone after Tamien I would have thought you were more townish. The not fearing death at night is kind of a strange thing for a townie.
You have played mafia before. You know this.

What set of people are you talking about when you say you can't all be mafia together? It's a bit unclear.

Yeah. Tamien definitely using ranked suspicion lists here.

modrony wrote:Here are my reasons for thinking Tamien is a light.

I originally caught them using a power on BSS.
BSS was very convincingly town so not investigative and didn't turn up dead so not harmful.
This made me think light.

I later did think that she might be a roleblocker instead but I really do not see how she could think to ask for clarification on a message that was addressed to 'Light' if she didn't have a healing power.
She did display an alarming lack of caution in responding to the things I said, which I find kind of confusing.

http://alicorn.elcenia.com/board/viewto ... oid#p12248
http://alicorn.elcenia.com/board/viewto ... 610#p12277
http://alicorn.elcenia.com/board/viewto ... age#p12794
http://alicorn.elcenia.com/board/viewto ... age#p12809

modrony i’ve been over your posts a bunch of times. if this is not the one you’re referring to then i don’t know what you mean, but she responded to this post and i guess i thought it was convincing enough.

oh i thought you meant the person who started advocating listposts, not the person who was doing the ranked suspicion lists. yeah that was tamien. she started it and i copied it for a litlte while after i started seeing it but ultimately it didn’t work for me so i stopped. i found i was more likely to grade people on how much i agreed with them by mistake so that’ why i stopped. i think she was right that suspicions posts have two ends and that people should include both ends. but her method of moving people between different groups didnt really work for me.

aand checked. Tamien was Sherlock in effulgence.
So her idea originally.

prevedit: yeah. Those are the links I was talking about.

modrony wrote:I meant the lists with the beginnings and the ends. The sherlock.. and that was Aestrix wasn't it? Argh need reread.
I do think Tamien kept up the practice here thou. A smart thing to do. Even if I now think it was camouflage.

I did tell you guys my reasons to think she was a light. It was not ironclad.
I posted links to them for you guys to look at.
So when you jumped to 99% on that I found it weird.

If you had gone after Tamien I would have thought you were more townish. The not fearing death at night is kind of a strange thing for a townie.
You have played mafia before. You know this.

What set of people are you talking about when you say you can't all be mafia together? It's a bit unclear.

you’re positing that me, jalapeno and tamien are all scum because we didn’t attack tamien. i’m saying we’re not. :P

from the way she was responding to you about the light thing, i dont think it was clear that she was a light, if she is one. maybe she wasn’t being subtle enough.

i disagree with you for a vanilla townie because being nightkilled is a kill that doesnt go to the power roles and also it’s a sign that you’re doing something right and making scum afraid of you. sometimes scum will bring you into LYLO even if they think you have a power role because they want to silence the people who are bieng right. maybe tamien wasn’t being right often enough. or maybe she’s scum. i dont have time to make a wall because the day will end but i did notice a few things about her in skimming through, for example she was hesitant to vote aestrix like jalapeno was.

I would totally have been doing Tamien-lists this whole game if I hadn't feared that you guys would have taken them way too seriously after my death.
I was kind of bummed that I couldn't do that.