Elcenia Mafia Game Thread

[futurevision]

I guess so, if he isn't a dragon(he is) then it might have been the light. Maybe it's wrong of me to assume that lights don't work during the day, since Chainsaw last game didn't work during the day.

[Kappa]

I don't even know why Chainsaw and lights would have anything to do with each other, and in my experience as a spectator last game, people making arguments based heavily on stating poorly-backed-up assumptions as fact tended to be evil. You're not making a good case for yourself here.

[futurevision]

My brain decided to make a connection between "night action that stops people from doing anything" and "action that stops people from being killed" and decided that they must work similarly in how long they lasted.

[modrony]

Thank you futurevision.
vote Tulip
I think they are intelligent enough that not getting the point of voting yesterday isn't really believable.
I do like the fact that they formed opinions today, but it doesn't lower my suspicion enough to get them below jalapeno at the moment.
This is subject to change when I read the thread again.

[Tulip]

I still don't get why voting yesterday was so important, even now. As I understand it, the argument in the early days was that we needed active voters to counter the No Lynch crew, but that's ceased to be a relevant concern, so I no longer see what's so valuable about everyone capable of voting doing so. Was it a piece of demon-related speculation that I missed somehow? That demons' votes don't count, or something?

Anyway, vote modrony for the reasons explained in my suspicion list. Open to revision if new evidence/arguments come along, et cetera, all the standard disclaimers wrt non-strongly-committed votes.

[BlueSkySprite]

Hey, not sure if this is a good idea, but do any dragons want to claim that they were attacked last night?

Also, futurevision has dropped to not the highest on my suspicion list. Partially because I have a guess about who they probably are and I think I don't want to kill them if they are that person.

@Kappa, I think Addy-copying-Chris to prevent people dying worked only at night?

[futurevision]

No, because last game michaelblume survived attempted lynching. But as Kappa pointed out, it's not particularly relevant to this game.

[BlueSkySprite]

No, I mean that Addy copied Chris at night, and I think she immediately used the Chris power on Chris, which then prevented a lynching?
I might be misremembering or misunderstanding, but I thought that that was what happened.
(I am using template names because these people are still playing and I don't want my opinions of current-players to be too influenced by who they were in previous games.)

[jalapeno_dude]

No, I mean that Addy copied Chris at night, and I think she immediately used the Chris power on Chris, which then prevented a lynching?

Yeah, that's what the postmortem says:

Day Two, you lynched AndaisQ (Charlie). At night, Libby let Voice out, Chainsaw tried to block Addy but Addy still had Bell's immunity, Addy poked michaelblume (Chris) and immediately protected same, Sherlock investigated Aestrix, Chelsea refriended Shoal, and Voice killed Tulip (Janine).

Day Three you tried to lynch michaelblume but he was protected.

[BlueSkySprite]

It would be cool if someone could double check this please?

Unofficial vote count:
Futurevision: 5 (BlueSkySprite, kappa, MTC, Paradox, Shoal)
Paradox: 1 (pistachi0n)
Tulip: 1 (modrony)
modrony: 1 (Tulip)
Nonvoters: 6 (Alphabeta, Anthusiasm, Futurevision, jalapeno_dude, michaelblume, Tamien)