Alicornutopia

Alphabeta: How sure are you about that?
It doesn't seem more likely to you that PDV is the vigilante?

Interesting. Sounds reasonable. The product of the two random large primes I generated with that site is 152062539501157482632286923, and I have told wolffreak in our communication channel what the two large primes were. I don’t know when wolffreak will next be online and able to post them, but I expect it’ll be before the end of the game day.

modrony wrote:Alphabeta: How sure are you about that?
It doesn't seem more likely to you that PDV is the vigilante?

I'm not very confident about it, but people jump on my ass when I suggest waiting to murder people. Rhysel's pretty murdery for an Elcenia character, but that's a pretty low bar to clear. Giving people kamai powers seems more like her thing, but that doesn't seem remotely balanced.

I'm still suspicious of MTC but I think I find plaindealingvillian more suspicious now so vote plaindealingvillian

modrony wrote:Also, it's weird Rithka is not a shren when she is one in wiki.

modrony wrote: MTC:
Private communication can be verified. Please do so.
Take two large primes, do: X*Y and post the result in the thread.
privately post the numbers to wolffreak.
Wolffreak should then post those.

This link has random prime generator.
https://primes.utm.edu/nthprime/index.php#random

This will at least solidify you are speaking the truth about the communication.

I'm don't think this will be very useful because if MTC is lying then they're both probably Mafia so they'd have private communication anyway. Probably worth doing anyway because I don't think there's any downside to it.

Paradox wrote: I'm don't think this will be very useful because if MTC is lying then they're both probably Mafia so they'd have private communication anyway. Probably worth doing anyway because I don't think there's any downside to it.

More solid info is always good.

I do feel that the dragon thing won't hold for long if it is a lie.
If that happens, we will know for certain that mafia has private communication and those two are in it.

Unvote MTC. I'm willing to accept that roleclaim for now. I'm not at all convinced of the PDV bandwagon—the only thing people seem to have on him is that he made a theorypost where he said he thought three deaths per cycle was more likely than two—so I'm going to stay voteless pending a reread of everyone's arguments to see who might actually be suspicious.

unvote wolffreak

I am going to avoid jumping on the PDV bandwagon because the only real evidence has been the thing where he speculated that there would be three deaths per cycle, which I think has turned out not to be true (although I might be misinterpreting his spec). I'm going to tentatively vote michaelblume because I put him in my untainted suspicions thing, but I'll probably change it before the end of the day if I get back online.

Tamien wrote:

I'm most convinced by the PDV crowd so far, given MTC's roleclaim vouching for wolffreak, although I remind you guys that roleclaims are weak evidence at best. vote PlainDealingVillain

Unofficial vote count:

PlainDealingVillain: 4 (Alpha, Shoal, Tamien, kappa)
MTC: 2 (Paradox, tau)
tau: 2 (jalapeno_dude, pistachi0n)
michaelblume: 1 (anthusiasum)
pistachi0n: 1 (modrony)
Abstentions: 7 (BlueSkySprite, futurevision, michaelblume, MTC, PlainDealingVillain, Tulip, wolffreak567)

My count might be off in places, because it's early in the morning and I might have missed some bold as I caught up.

Paradox and tau have both moved their votes to PDV. Apart from that my vote count agrees with yours.

I’ll vote for PlainDealingVillain too. Out of the players with votes, he is the one I’m most suspicious of.