Alicornutopia

I think Pokémon among other settings would be tonally wrong for Silmaril.

Aw, Oh well.

I want to do more with Elf Bell. She will probably not have a chance to appear in Silmaril, at least not in her fully realized form, because competent Valar are a bit much, but I super want to sandbox her. Sandboxes that do not call for the presence of any of lintamande's Elves are most convenient for any proposed sandboxes with people other than lintamande.

Brain: "Elf Bell stranded in a world with Different Elfs, like Thilanushinyel (presence of Sarion optional) or Thedas or something. Or Cetaganda. Haut count."

I do not have any immediately brilliant ideas but this sounds really good to me.

House Elves probably don't count. But Carp Elves should, if there's a plot there.

Elf Bell being utterly horrified at the existence of some world that we'd consider to be made of cotton candy.

How would Elves react to chronicle?

A lot of bad things actually do happen in Chronicle, although they are seldom permanent except for people being a usual amount of mortal; it's a matter of tone and how people feel about them (e.g. is it an annoyance or a life-ruining trauma to be kidnapped by a dragon). Elves would probably actually find Chronicle weirdly Stepfordy.

Huh. Stepfordy in what sense?