Alicornutopia

my choice: pistachi0n
"It's only after death that we find out which one of their speculations was their actual power, and what can the mafia do about it then? Kill them even more?"
I feel they are way too confident about the lists being perfectly non-informative.
Also voting for no lynch is the safest choice next to wagoning Aesterix.
I do confess that this is my revised opinion and not the one I first wrote down. Upon reading the thread again, this time without being distracted, I was unable to understand my first choice.

I am also suspicious of wolffreak567 for only having a single post.
He gets some slack for being new but BSS did say: "This one actually plays online mafia a fair amount!" so it's not inconceivable that he requested a scum role.

From what I saw, Alphabeta was by far the most overtly suspicious of all of us. Where the vast majority of people took no suspicious actions I could see, Alphabeta has repeatedly refused to involve himself in any of the town-beneficial day-one tactics we came up with:

• Back when it was the best idea we'd had, he refused to join in the RNG vote.
• He refused to join in Kappa's power-revealing plan.
• He voted for Kappa, who is the main person spearheading the town's push to use the best tactics we can collectively think of.
• And, in voting for Kappa publicly, he also blew his ability to join in the town's anti-idea-contamination campaign.

I'd probably write off any one of those things on its own as just a non-suspicious personal preference, but put together into a list like that? It paints a pretty clear picture of non-compatibility with the town's goals. It's actually a much stronger cluster of evidence than I expected to pick up on day one.