Alicornutopia

Yes indeed.

So history time! The glowfic site was in fact originally designed with that style in mind. But the largest problem was actually imports. There's a lot of historical glowfic that I'd probably import- and even if I just import Effulgence, there's a bunch of threaded style things there- and those ones, like the Cam summoning post, start to get a bit weird if you don't have a top index post. I can probably still go back to that approach, but I might have to tear out the currently theoretical ability to thread things in the process, and I don't know how strongly people feel about no top post vs threading.

Is there some way to like... have one post with multiple "versions", or "subheadings", or something, so that you can import posts like that and people can do multithreaded posts but in the individual threads the top-level will still only appear at the start...?

You could just import the threads separately, like five different threads called "call me maybe" with the same text in their top post.

That seems untidy; there should be some sort of provision for it, I think. It should be theoretically possible...?

I mean, most things are *possible*, but vary by time required, and there's also a significant factor of "how much time would I invest in this vs the other tasks on my list". And this one would probably be a large time investment.

Pushed out a couple fixes by Throne3d; the /characters pages shouldn't crash when you're logged out and timestamps should be 1-12 not 0-11.

I kind of like having the top post be a thing. That way when I follow the link from the mini-notifications thread, I can go "what was this thread again? oh right, that was the premise" and then keep reading from where the new comments are.

Keeping the top post is somewhat incompatible with some other desirable things. For example:

DanielH wrote:Dreamwidth shows the post at the top of each page but scrolls past it when you change pages. That behavior seems best here too.

If you do this, then when you refresh the page (i.e. to check for new tags), it will scroll to the top of the page unless you fiddle with the URL. This is workable, but obnoxious.

My suggestion would be for the div containing the top post to be hideable, and to default to hidden on any page that isn't the first. This isn't hard and I can probably code it myself.

Huh, that would need to be coded up. I didn’t realize that Firefox and IE both lacked support for the <details> element.

PDV's suggestion is way better than most things I've come up with; top post being toggleable can totally be a thing (or a user setting or whatever).